Corante

About this Insider
Simple enough: everything having to do with podcasting.
About these Authors
EDITOR
Alex Williams Alex Williams
( Profile | Archive )

CONTRIBUTORS
Matt May Matt May
( Profile | Archive )

Nicole Simon Nicole Simon
( Profile | Archive )

Roland Tanglao Roland Tanglao
( Profile | Archive )

Matt May is a Web accessibility specialist, and has written on the interaction of people and technology since 1995. He keeps his own weblog at bestkungfu.com, and produces a podcast called Staccato, which features Creative Commons-licensed music.

Alex Williamsblogs, consults and produces unconference style events, where people immerse in DIY media. These are fun occasions, designed for people who want to get together with authors, artists, technologists and leading thinkers to converse, eat, listen to music, write, shoot photos and post podcasts and videoblogs. Alex also works with companies to establish DIY approaches, where writing, photography, voice and video come together to create new conversations and communities. Alex is currently fascinated with digital photography. His girlfriend calls him a Flickrholic. Send Alex a nice message: alexhwilliams at gmail.com.

Nicole Simon loves blogging and podcasting, dashed with an European view. As consultant she helps to facilitate such tools for business purposes or personal publishing empires. She can be found at cruel to be kind and on her private blog Useful Sounds.

Roland Tanglao is a well known podcasting enthusiast and a passionate advocate of blogs, RSS, and social software as a means of online expression for people, organizations and businesses. He is a prominent participant in the blogosphere and online communities and one of the founders of Bryght and as Bryght's Chief Blogging Officer reads hundreds of blogs daily. He graduated from the University of Waterloo, worked at Nortel Networks where he ran its first internal corporate blog, has has been blogging since 1999, and was the first business blogging consultant in Canada.

Podcasting

« Joi Ito's Web Poses A Question About Quoting Written Articles | Main | Where Does Podcasting Fit With Google Music? »

December 15, 2005

Wikipedia Not Much Worse Than Britannica

Email This Entry

Posted by Alex Williams

It may be scrutinized about its posts for the history of podcasting but as far as science goes, Wikipedia's accuracy is on par with Britannica.

That's what Nature is reporting:

...And podcasting pioneer Adam Curry has been accused of editing the entry on podcasting to remove references to competitors' work. Curry says he merely thought he was making the entry more accurate.

However, an expert-led investigation carried out by Nature — the first to use peer review to compare Wikipedia and Britannica's coverage of science — suggests that such high-profile examples are the exception rather than the rule.

The exercise revealed numerous errors in both encyclopaedias, but among 42 entries tested, the difference in accuracy was not particularly great: the average science entry in Wikipedia contained around four inaccuracies; Britannica, about three.

So, isn't this saying that Wikipedia essentialy has its own peer review network that compares in quality to the systems and processes the encyclopedia folks follow? And so why are we flapping about Wikipedia? What about the millions of bloggers and podcasters who flout all kinds of questionably accurate statements?

Comments (0) + TrackBacks (0) | Category: News and Commentary


POST A COMMENT




Remember Me?



EMAIL THIS ENTRY TO A FRIEND

Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):




RELATED ENTRIES
Test post January 24
Podcast Award Nominations Shows Lack of Understanding
Odeo Moving Beyond Podcasts With Twttr
The Talent Search Has Begun
Constraint Based DIY Media
Will Scoble Do For Podcasting What He Did For Blogging?
Forrester study: If 25% are interested I would hurry
Is your tax professional podcasting?